It Took 4.5 Years to Build Golden Gate Bridge; San Fran’s Newly Approved Public Bank May Take Longer

SAN FRANCISCO—San Francisco voters approved a measure establishing a path toward a city-owned bank, but the proposal faces years of potential delays, significant costs and regulatory obstacles before such an institution could accept deposits, according to an analysis by GrowSF.org.

As the CU Daily reported here, Proposition B received about 53% support in the November election. The measure authorizes a two-stage approach that would begin with a municipal finance corporation to support housing, small businesses and environmental projects, with the possibility of eventually converting it into a public bank.

The ballot measure did not provide funding. The city controller estimated combined capital and operating costs of $310 million to $460 million over eight years if the city proceeds, although the estimate carries substantial uncertainty, GrowSF reported.

The First Step

The first step would require funding from city officials or outside sources. The municipal finance corporation could make loans but could not accept deposits. It would be overseen by a nine-member commission and a five-member corporate board.

Under Proposition B, the corporation would have to operate continuously for at least three years before its board or oversight commission could initiate a transition to a public bank. If operations began in 2027, that process could not begin before 2030, and regulatory approvals would still be required.

GrowSF identified a potential conflict with California’s existing public-bank licensing law, which has a window set to expire in 2028. Unless state lawmakers extend that deadline, the city could be unable to seek a license after satisfying the three-year operating requirement.

Viability Study Needed

The San Francisco Board of Supervisors would also need to approve a viability study and vote to proceed with a bank application. Although the board accepted a study in 2023, it has not voted to apply, according to GrowSF.

Any deposit-taking bank would need a state license and federal deposit insurance. GrowSF noted that the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. has said it closely scrutinizes applications involving government-owned banks because of concerns including political influence, management stability and access to capital. The Bank of North Dakota and the Territorial Bank of American Samoa, two government-owned banks, operate without FDIC insurance.

Additional Constraint

Another constraint would apply if the bank held city deposits. California generally requires eligible securities securing public deposits to have a collateral value equal to 110% of the deposits, although requirements vary by collateral type. That could limit the amount of public deposits available to support lending.

The vote therefore established a possible route to public banking rather than an immediately operational bank. Whether the proposal advances will depend on financing, additional city action and state and federal regulatory decisions.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.