What Credit Unions Should Demand From Fintech Partners in 2027

By Mark Bashforth

Credit unions have spent years modernizing their technology by stacking new capabilities designed to improve operations and better serve members. However, adding technology alone doesn’t fully solve the institutional or member problem that prompted investment in the first place.

As credit unions look toward 2027, leaders should ask whether their fintech partners are truly helping accomplish what the credit union initially hired them to achieve. That answer requires looking beyond product features and contractual obligations. To ensure strong partnerships, credit unions should raise the standard for fintech relationships around execution, alignment, and accountability. 

Demand an Execution Plan, Not Just a Good Sales Pitch

A compelling demo can help a credit union see what’s possible. Once the agreement is signed, however, the real test begins. 

Credit unions and their fintech partners should begin by agreeing on the implementation timeline and what each side is expected to deliver, including:

  • Who owns each part of the implementation? Clear ownership on both sides keeps tasks from falling through the cracks.
  • What are the major milestones? Concrete milestones give both teams a shared definition of progress.
  • When will progress be reviewed? Scheduled checkpoints surface problems while there’s still time to fix them.
  • What happens when something doesn’t go according to plan? Agreeing on how to handle delays and setbacks up front prevents finger-pointing later.

Just as important, both sides must agree on the problem they’re trying to solve and what success should look like after deployment, not just at go-live. “We went live” shouldn’t automatically mean “the partnership succeeded.”

Align Incentives Around Outcomes, Not Contractual Obligations

A provider can fulfill every requirement in a contract and still fall short of what the credit union expected from the relationship. That’s why credit unions should establish shared measures of success tied to the reason the technology was purchased, such as membership growth or a better member experience.

Still, many fintech sales reps are measured on closing the deal and earning a commission, not on what happens after the initial startup period. Credit unions should look for partners whose success is tied to the results the credit union achieves to ensure a long-term, mutually beneficial partnership. 

Product roadmaps also belong in this discussion. If a credit union chose a solution partly because of a promised future capability, leaders should understand whether it’s still coming and when.

Establish the Non-Negotiables Before the Relationship Starts

Credit unions are risk averse, but clear requirements up front can ease much of that caution. To establish this, credit unions should develop a checklist of non-negotiables before the first demo and hold every provider to it. 

  • Data ownership and privacy always come first on this list. The credit union should remain in control of its data and know exactly how a partner can access and use it. If a provider can effectively own the data or use it in ways the credit union can’t control, that’s a non-starter.
  • Security is next. Providers should have to prove their technology has been properly vetted, including standards such as SOC 2 compliance. It should be scrutinized from day one, not treated as a box-checking exercise after the organization has effectively chosen a provider.
  • Equally important, the exit clause. It may feel awkward to raise at the start of a promising relationship, but a credit union needs a realistic way to end the partnership if things stop working, rather than being stuck in a five-year contract. No provider should become so embedded that the credit union is effectively held hostage, and the right contingencies should be in place. 

Credit Unions Should Get Smarter Together

Credit unions are naturally cautious adopters of emerging technology, and for good reason. They carry significant responsibilities around risk. But that caution doesn’t need to become a disadvantage. The cooperative nature of the industry gives institutions an opportunity to reduce uncertainty by learning from one another. Industry associations, conferences, and technology-focused peer groups are natural places to share practical implementation lessons, including what worked and where implementation became difficult.

Fintech providers have a role, too. They can support user groups, ideally run by users rather than the vendor, where existing customers share candid experiences with prospective ones. It takes transparency and trust, but everyone benefits. Prospects get honest feedback, and providers gain new exposure and user input to refine their solutions. Credit unions don’t all need to learn the same lessons independently, and greater transparency about what happens after a technology decision is made can shorten the learning curve for everyone.

Manage Fintech Relationships Like a Portfolio

Fintech selection shouldn’t be treated as a one-time purchasing decision. Technology partnerships need active management after the contract is signed and the implementation is complete. Approach these relationships like portfolio investments: assign clear ownership and evaluate performance against the return the credit union expected, whether that’s membership growth, better processes or a stronger member experience.

Make someone responsible for the relationship rather than assuming the provider or IT team will manage its performance. Then hold regular reviews, ideally quarterly, centered on the questions that matter:

  • Are we getting the outcome we expected?
  • What are we hearing from members and users?
  • What is working, and what is not?
  • Has the product roadmap changed?
  • Are the expected capabilities arriving when promised?
  • And, ultimately, does this partnership still merit our investment and attention? 

The board should back the decision, too, and want to see it through. Credit unions that don’t put in the effort can’t expect the return, much like showing up to the Boston Marathon without having trained. Without checkpoints, it’s hard to validate the outcome.

Raise the Standard for Partnership

Modernization can’t simply mean adding another product to the technology stack. Credit unions should expect fintech partners to execute effectively and share accountability for outcomes while protecting the institution’s autonomy. They should also expect those partners to remain responsive as member needs change.

The real measure of a fintech partnership is whether it helps the credit union serve its members better while preserving the institution’s ability to determine what comes next.

Mark Bashforth is a partner at Black Dragon Capital.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.