Have the Conversation About Your OD Fees Now–or Prepare to Have it With Congress Later

By Jason Stverak

Credit unions should expect another fight over overdraft fees in the next Congress. We need to be ready to defend our members.

A recent CU Daily report says U.S. banks collected $1.6 billion in overdraft fees during the third quarter, the highest quarterly total in four years. That is a headline certain to attract attention on Capitol Hill. It is also a bank revenue figure. It does not, by itself, tell Congress whether an individual credit union’s program is fair, what choices its members have, or what happens when a payment is declined.

As the 120th Congress prepares to convene, I expect overdraft and nonsufficient funds fees to become a prominent oversight issue. Credit unions should prepare for hearings and pointed letters. I also expect some lawmakers to use fee totals to paint banks and credit unions as taking advantage of struggling families. We should answer legitimate questions. But I will push back against anyone who treats every credit union as guilty before asking how its program works.

‘Know Your Program’

Here is what I am telling credit union leaders: Know your program. Be able to explain what it costs, why you charge what you charge, and how it helps your members. If you cannot answer those questions clearly, fix the program before someone else tries to fix it for you.

DCUC has been encouraging credit unions to prepare for scrutiny for years. Do not wait until a congressional letter lands on your desk. Your board should be able to sit down with a member who has paid a fee and explain, in plain English, why the policy makes sense.

The member-owned structure matters here. Credit union members elect their boards. There are no outside stockholders demanding a bigger return. Decisions about services and fees affect the people who own the institution, and those people deserve a meaningful say through their elected representatives. Credit unions must follow the law, and regulators have a job to do. That does not mean Washington should make every business decision for them.

If your credit union wants to eliminate overdraft or NSF fees, great. Do it. If reducing fees, adding a grace period, or offering another affordable way to cover an emergency works better for your membership, pursue it. Another credit union may find that a reasonably priced overdraft program is something its members want to keep. Washington should respect that choice, too.

Let the Owners be the Drivers

The people who own the credit union should drive that decision through the board they elect. A government bureaucrat should not get to decide that one approach is right for every membership in the country.

DCUC’s record on this issue is public. In April 2024, we opposed California’s SB 1075 and warned that restrictions on overdraft and NSF practices could disrupt services for military families. In May 2024, we raised related concerns with congressional committees. Our December 2024 letters to Congress and the CFPB opposed the agency’s final overdraft rule and urged enforcement against abusive practices while preserving responsible services.

We carried that argument into 2025, supporting congressional action to overturn the rule. In my December 2, 2025, letter to Senator Elizabeth Warren, I defended the cooperative model while emphasizing reasonable fees, transparency, and continuous improvement. I also made clear that members should not be caught in recurring fee cycles. That remains our position.

Defending credit unions requires knowing what a program actually does. Overdraft coverage pays a transaction despite insufficient funds. An NSF fee generally accompanies a transaction returned unpaid. Those are different outcomes, and credit unions must explain and justify them separately. An institution cannot defend an NSF charge simply by pointing to the value of paying a member’s bill when that particular bill was returned.

Every board and executive team should know why each fee exists and how its amount was set. Know the costs and risks. Know how often members pay, whether the same households keep getting charged, and what you waive or refund. “We have always done it this way” will not satisfy a member. It certainly will not hold up at a congressional hearing.

Shouldn’t Require a Law Degree

A member should not need a lawyer to understand the program. Explain when fees apply, which transactions are covered, and how balances and payment processing affect the result. Make the choices about participation clear, including what happens if a member declines coverage. If you offer alerts, fee limits, grace periods, or hardship assistance, make sure members know about them and can actually use them.

Look at the alternatives, too. Can a member use a linked savings transfer or an affordable small-dollar loan? If the same member keeps overdrawing, someone should ask what is going wrong and offer help. Credit unions should be able to show whether their response helps that person regain financial stability. Keeping a program financially sound matters. So does knowing what it is doing for the people using it.

Check your vendors, too. A policy approved by the board is only as good as the way it works in a member’s account. If processing practices produce charges you cannot explain or defend, address them. The member’s relationship is with the credit union. That is where accountability belongs.

Consider a military family moving to a new duty station. An unexpected expense arrives before a reimbursement, and the spouse handling the bills needs a way to cover the gap. A reasonably priced overdraft option may help. Another product may be better. The family deserves clear choices and practical help. A congressional press release will not cover that payment.

Congress Needs to Know

Before Congress restricts an option, it needs to answer what happens to the member afterward. A declined payment may bring a merchant penalty or a late charge somewhere else. Taking away a credit union fee does not put the missing money in the family’s account. Lawmakers should examine the full cost to the member, including whether an affordable alternative is actually available.

I will work with anyone in either party who wants to make financial services better for our members. Credit unions should answer fair questions and correct mistakes. But if a hearing starts with the assumption that charging a fee makes a credit union predatory, we are going to push back. Judge the institution by how it treats its members. Give it a fair opportunity to explain its record.

Have This Conversation Now

My advice to credit union leaders is to have this conversation now. Tell your members how the program works. Make sure your board understands it. Take your explanation to your congressional delegation before the next hearing. When you can show that your program serves your members well, stand behind it.

At DCUC, we will keep defending the ability of credit unions to serve their members, including those who wear our nation’s uniform. We will support credit unions that choose to eliminate fees. We will also defend fair, transparent programs that members value and want to keep.

Let credit unions serve their members. The members own these institutions. Washington does not.

Jason Stverak is chief advocacy officer, Defense Credit Union Council.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.