WASHINGTON — Former National Credit Union Administration Chairman Todd Harper expressed confidence Tuesday after a federal appeals court heard arguments over President Donald Trump’s removal of Harper and fellow board member Tanya Otsuka, although judges questioned whether the credit union regulator is entitled to the same independence protections as the Federal Reserve.
The Nov. 17 hearing took place before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, not the federal district court that originally ruled in the former board members’ favor. The appeal concerns whether Trump could dismiss the two Senate-confirmed Democrats without cause in April 2025.
“WALK TALL,” Harper wrote in a statement after the hearing. “Our lawsuit to overturn the President’s unlawful removal of Tanya Otsuka and me and return us to our Senate-confirmed seats on the NCUA board has taken a giant step forward.”

‘We Will Win’
“After the US District Court of Appeals heard oral arguments today, I remain confident that, when all is said and done, we will win,” Harper added, referring to the appellate proceedings.
Bloomberg Law reported that members of the appellate panel appeared skeptical of the former board members’ argument that the NCUA is comparable to the Federal Reserve, with its headline over reporting on the hearing describing the judges as ‘frosty.” Judge Cornelia T.L. Pillard noted differences between the agencies, saying, “I don’t take the NCUA to be setting monetary policy.” The questioning does not establish how the court will rule.
Harper maintained that independence is central to the dispute. He argued that both agencies supervise financial institutions, provide liquidity and set interest rates, and that their traditions of independence can be traced to early banking institutions and, in the credit union movement’s case, colonial-era friendly societies.
“The court should rule in our favor and preserve the independence of financial institutions regulators,” Harper said.
The Legal Fight
The legal fight began after Trump removed Harper and Otsuka in April 2025. In July of that year, U.S. District Judge Amir H. Ali ruled their dismissals unlawful, finding that Congress had restricted the president’s ability to remove NCUA board members before their terms expired. The ruling briefly restored them to the board, but an appeals court stay subsequently kept them out of office while the administration challenged the decision.
As The CU Daily reported in September, Justice Department attorneys contend the Federal Credit Union Act contains no explicit language limiting the president’s removal authority and argue that the district court’s ruling should be overturned. Harper and Otsuka counter that the law’s structure, fixed board terms and the NCUA’s regulatory responsibilities support protection against removal without cause.
The dispute has also been shaped by Supreme Court decisions this year involving the removal of officials at independent agencies. Harper and Otsuka argue that the court’s treatment of the Federal Reserve supports their case; the administration relies on broader presidential removal authority recognized in litigation involving the Federal Trade Commission.
Harper’s term is set to expire in April 2027 and Otsuka’s in August 2029. The NCUA, which is designed to have a three-member board, currently operates with Chairman John Crews as its sole board member.
The appeals court did not issue a decision at Tuesday’s hearing. A ruling could determine whether Harper and Otsuka return to the board and help define the extent of presidential control over the federal credit union regulator.






2 Responses
Time to move on, take your talents to the speaking circuit. We need fresh blood and get the seats filled
Agreed. This fight is tired and wasteful, but it makes for great TED talks!