NCLC Urges Bank App Filed by Fintech Dave be Rejected; Alleges APRs of More Than 500%

WASHINGTON — The National Consumer Law Center is urging federal regulators to reject an application by financial technology company Dave to establish an insured national bank, alleging the company uses a payday lending model that imposes high costs on consumers and could circumvent state interest rate limits.

In a statement, the consumer advocacy group said Dave has applied to the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. to establish Dave Bank. The group argued that a national bank charter could allow the company to offer loans nationwide at rates exceeding caps imposed by individual states.

“Dave is a disguised payday lender that is being sued by the Trump Administration and does not deserve to be a national bank,” said Lauren Saunders, a senior attorney at the National Consumer Law Center.

The group contends that Dave presents its cash advances as overdrafts on deposit accounts established for customers rather than as loans. That characterization, it argues, allows the company to claim it charges no interest while assessing fees on advances.

APR of 521%

According to the NCLC, Dave charges $5 or 5% of an advance, whichever is greater. It calculated that a $5 fee on a $50 advance repaid in seven days is equivalent to an annual percentage rate of about 521%. The organization said lawsuits filed by Baltimore and the district attorney in Montgomery County, Pennsylvania, have alleged rates reaching 2,500% under some circumstances.

The NCLC also cited litigation challenging the company’s practices. In Russell v. Dave, it said, a federal district court rejected Dave’s argument that its advances were not credit and determined that overdraft fees, expedited delivery fees and tips could qualify as finance charges under the Military Lending Act, which limits covered lending costs for service members.

Federal Case Cited

Separately, the organization pointed to a federal case originally brought by the Federal Trade Commission and pursued by the Justice Department. It said a court found the government had plausibly alleged that Dave misled consumers about advance amounts, costs and representations concerning the use of tips to support meals. Those findings concern the sufficiency of allegations, not a final determination that the claims were proved.

The consumer group warned that frequent use of short-term advances can deepen financial hardship by encouraging repeated borrowing and accumulating fees.

The center compared Dave’s application with earlier attempts by fintech lenders Opportunity Financial, known as OppFi, and Enova to acquire national bank charters. It said both companies withdrew their applications following opposition and regulatory scrutiny.

‘One Thing in Mind’

“Predatory lenders are applying for bank charters with one thing in mind: circumventing state limits on high interest rates and increasing profits at all costs,” Saunders said. “If Dave’s bank charter application is approved, people and families already hit hardest by the affordability crisis will pay the price.”

The allegations and characterizations in the statement are those of the National Consumer Law Center. The statement did not include a response from Dave or the federal banking regulators, and approval of the proposed bank has not been established.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

2 Responses

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.