Alleging Violations of Law, Self-Dealing, California Regulator Urged to Review Proposed BECU/SAFE Merger

SACRAMENTO, Calif.–A group of members from SAFE Credit Union—with support from others within the credit union community–is pressing California’s Department of Financial Protection and Innovation to pause and review the proposed merger between SAFE and Seattle-based BECU.

As the CU Daily has been reporting, the merger of the $4.3-billion SAFE CU into the $29.4-billion BECU has been controversial and has been publicly challenged by at least one member and by three former credit union CEOs, all of whom have authored opinion pieces published in local media. In addition, Chip Filson, the former director of examination and insurance with NCUA and a co-founder of Callahan & Associates, has also published a new blog past critical of not just the SAFE/BECU combination, but other trends in credit union mergers, as well. 

As the CU Daily has also been reporting, the $4.3-billion SAFE CU is looking to merge into the $29.4-billion BECU to create a $33-billion operation with more than 1.8 million members and more than 80 locations under BECU’s charter. If approved, it would be the fourth-largest credit union in the country. 

The deal includes $15 million in payouts from SAFE CU’s capital to five members of its management team,

Member voting closed at the end of October. SAFE has not released the results of the member vote or any information on how many members voted. 

Law Allow SAFE to Appeal Directly to Regulator 

While California law requires state-chartered CUs seeking to merge to get an affirmative vote by a majority of members, of which SAFE CU has nearly 250,000, as reported here, under California Financial Code Section 15201(b), a credit union’s board may also apply to the California Commissioner of Financial Institutions “For approval of a merger in accordance with a plan of merger approved by a majority of the board of directors of each credit union that is a party to the merger, even though less than a majority of the outstanding members of a disappearing credit union has voted to approve the merger…”

When the CU Daily earlier sought comment from the DFPI on the SAFE merger application, the department declined comment, pointing the CU Daily toward a section of the financial code that has to do with mergers, dissolutions and conversions. 

Members Ask for Review

Now, the CU Daily has been told, a group of members has petitioned the department, asking it to review the merger and alleging SAFE Credit Union has violated consumer protection laws in California, that it did not fully disclose to members all the information they would need to cast a vote, and alleging self-dealing by the five members of management who are to receive approximately $15 million in payouts as a result of the merger. 

The CU Daily has also been in contact with others who have reached out to DFPI Chief Deputy Commissioner Suzanne Martindale have asked the agency to recognize, among other issues, that many credit union members to not fully understand that the capital belongs to them and they have ownership rights; ignorance that insiders within credit unions are leveraging to personally profit from. 

Another allegation made is that BECU is significantly underpaying for the “book value” of SAFE.

It should be noted that several others have, in response to some of the allegations made by critics of the merger, argued that SAFE members are not any equity since it transfers to BECU in any merger and that they retain their membership. 

Opponents of the merger have also expressed hope that Rohit Chopra, the former head of the CFPB who now leads California’s new Business and Consumer Services Agency, will also take an interest in the proposed merger and potentially pause the deal for a review. 

The CU Daily has reached out to SAFE Credit Union for comment and will update this reporting is comment is provided.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

2 Responses

  1. Election denying at its best.

    …” have asked the agency to recognize, among other issues, that many credit union members to not fully understand that the capital belongs to them and they have ownership rights; “

    At what point does a member owner or voter have to take responsibility? Member ignorance and apathy is on them. Those that voted yes very likely understand that the capital of the combined credit union belongs to them on the save exact way it did before the merger, only that there is more of it.

    All the disclosures were within requirements, including SAFE’s intention of asking the CA DFPI to use the authority they have, which was legislated to contemplate this exact scenario of a less than a majority of member yes vote. Pay for execs in mergers has occurred for decades and regulators are going to intervene on that issue. Members that voted, and the Board voted in to represent the entire membership, approved it.

    I don’t know why there is unusual interest in this merger, but it’s not unique in anyway to other mergers and it will be approved, just as it should be.

    Maybe it can be used to highlight the issue of why as CU leaders we think members care about being part of a member-owned cooperative way more than they really do. Start with the total dilution of the common bond concept over time. The bank lobby makes silly arguments like 990 disclosure. If they were smart, they would throw the chronic and systemic lack of member engagement in this member cooperative model we stand on to justify the tax exemption right back in our face.

  2. Seriously anti-consumer reply. Can tell you are one of the CEOs that would sell your charter for $1 million or $4. After all, it’s the ignorant members that don’t understand you are selling their charter to fund your big payday.

    Disgustingly unethical response. What are credit unions coming to?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.